San Diego International Law Journal Issue Search
|Title||A Global Crisis Writ Large: The Effects of Being “Stateless In Thailand” on Hill-Tribe Children|
|Author(s)||Joy Park, John Tanagho, and Mary E. Weicher Gaudet|
|Abstract|| According to the United Nations High Commission for Refugees (UNHCR), "[n]o region of the world has been left untouched by the statelessness issue." International law defines a stateless person as someone "who is not considered as a national by any state under the operation of its law." Yet across the nations, stateless persons do not desire citizenship simply for the sake of citizenship. Ultimately, citizenship, or membership in a nation, provides a link between an individual and that nation and carries with it fundamental benefits and rights. Correspondingly,lack of citizenship translates into a denial of benefits and rights, including basic human rights. The global crisis of statelessness is emphasized and highlighted by the struggle for citizenship of Thailand’s hill-tribes. The hill-tribes, or "chao khao," are minority ethnic groups that live in villages in the mountains of northern Thailand. Almost half of all hill-tribe people are stateless. Thailand is their true home, and for most, has been their home for generations. Most hill-tribe people were born in Thailand, and one or both of their parents were also born in Thailand. Thus, they are legally eligible for Thai citizenship under Thai law. In reality, however, forty to sixty percent of hill-tribe people who qualify for Thai citizenship remain without it. In point of fact, many hill-tribe people already are Thai citizens under the law: Thai laws actually provide detailed specifications regarding who is eligible for citizenship. For these people legal eligibility is not the issue. The central issue is whether, in practice, the Thai government recognizes their citizenship and provides them with corresponding documentation or proof. There are approximately 400,000 stateless hill-tribe people in Thailand today. These hill-tribes are denied many benefits and rights on account of their legal status. For example, they are ineligible for the Thai national healthcare plan that benefits people below a certain income level because only Thai citizens are eligible for the plan. Many hill-tribe people, therefore, have either no access to healthcare, limited access through non-governmental organizations (“NGOs”), or access healthcare but are forced to pay an unaffordable rate. Lack of citizenship also restricts the freedom of movement of hill-tribes outside their villages and provinces. It is already difficult for hill-tribes to obtain non-agricultural jobs. Travel restrictions applicable to non-citizens further narrow their opportunities to access other employment and education. Lack of Thai citizenship also prevents hill-tribe people from joining labor unions, owning land, and voting in political elections. The denial of these fundamental rights places hill-tribe people at a higher risk for social and economic exploitation in the forms of sex trafficking and abusive labor. The United Nations Educational Scientific and Cultural Organization ("UNESCO") reports that "[i]n Thailand . . . a lack of proof of citizenship is the single greatest risk factor for a hill-tribe girl or woman to be trafficked or otherwise exploited." This increased risk of sexual exploitation translates into a greater likelihood that hill-tribe women and girls will contract HIV/AIDS.
In addition to being at greater for commercial exploitation, one of the greatest obstacles to social advancement facing stateless hill-tribe children is access to basic, quality education. Although Thailand’s Ministry of Education has mandated that all children have the right to twelve years of free education, the first nine being compulsory, many hill-tribe children do not benefit from this policy. Many schools are either unaware of these recent education regulations or know about the laws but choose to discriminate against hill-tribe children. As a result, some hill-tribe children struggle simply to enroll in a Thai public school. If children do succeed in enrolling in primary school, the quality of education they receive often does not match that of other schools. The quality of schools in hill-tribe villages, which are located in remote highland areas, is far inferior to Thai public schools located in and near large cities. Hill-tribe children who overcome these obstacles and graduate face further complications as many school officials stamp their diploma with bright red letters indicating that the student is not a Thai citizen. The Thai government has taken a step in the right direction by clarifying that education is for "all" and that "all" includes children who lack Thai citizenship. Furthermore, many active international organizations ("IOs") and NGOs are working to assist the hill-tribes. Some of these organizations provide healthcare, some provide education, and some assist hill-tribe people with the citizenship application process. Yet hill-tribe people and their children continue to encounter the same problems. This Article argues that the Thai government and NGOs must attack the root of the problem: lack of citizenship. While providing hill-tribes with social services fulfills a great need, it only treats the symptoms or effects of statelessness. The solution is to recognize hill-tribe people as Thai citizens.
This Article clarifies the current state of Thai citizenship and education laws and sheds light upon the unjust treatment stateless hill-tribe people face in these areas. It highlights the denial of rights through the lens of education, examining the various struggles of hill-tribe children. The Article provides background information about the hill-tribes and outlines the current citizenship and education laws that apply to them. It then analyzes the implementation of Thai citizenship and education laws, discussing the main obstacles to their success. The Article also discusses in detail a recent 2008 UNESCO study on the magnitude and effects of statelessness on the hill-tribes. Finally, the Article makes practical proposals directed towards Thailand’s government and NGOs that are working with the hill-tribes towards the recognition of their legal and human rights. These proposals include educating Thai government and education officials on the statelessness problem and the relevant laws, ensuring that all children are registered at birth, and bringing together international and local NGOs for broader collaboration.